Why you need one
You have somewhere between 80 and 200 accounts. A human cannot hold 200 unique random passwords, so without software the choices are reuse, a notebook, or a pattern, and attackers have tooling for all three. A password manager removes the constraint: it generates a unique 20-character password for every site, fills it in, and asks you to remember exactly one secret. Every serious security body, from NIST to the UK’s NCSC, recommends one.
The common objection is “what if the manager gets breached?” It is a fair question with a good answer: a properly built manager never has your passwords. It has an encrypted blob that only your master password can open, and that decryption happens on your device. The 2022 LastPass breach is the cautionary tale: attackers got the vaults, and users with strong master passwords were fine while users with weak ones were not.
What actually matters
- Zero-knowledge architecture. The vault is encrypted on your device with a key derived from your master password; the company cannot read it. Every major manager claims this. Look for a public security whitepaper describing the key derivation (PBKDF2 with 600,000+ iterations, or Argon2id).
- Independent audits. Published third-party security audits, ideally yearly, and a bug bounty. Open-source code is a bonus because it has been read by more people, not because it is automatically safer.
- Fills where you live. Browser extensions for the browsers you use, apps for your phone with autofill integration, and a desktop app if you want one. A manager you have to copy-paste from gets abandoned.
- Sharing that fits your life. Family plans with shared folders for the Netflix login, or team vaults for work. Sharing by pasting a password into a chat is the thing you are trying to stop.
- Export. You must be able to leave. A manager that cannot export to CSV or a standard format is holding your data hostage.
- A recovery story you understand. What happens when you forget the master password? Options range from “nothing, it is gone” (most secure, most scary) to emergency contacts and recovery kits. Know the answer before you need it.
What is mostly marketing
- “Military-grade AES-256 encryption.” Everyone uses AES-256. The differentiator is key derivation and implementation, not the cipher.
- Dark-web monitoring. Useful, but it is usually a wrapper around Have I Been Pwned, which you can check free with our breach checker.
- Password strength scores. Most managers use a simple meter. Our strength checker is stricter; a manager-generated random password will pass both.
- Built-in VPNs and identity theft insurance. Bundles, not password management.
The categories
- Cloud-synced services (Bitwarden, 1Password, Proton Pass, Dashlane, NordPass): the mainstream choice. Sync across devices, sharing, recovery options. Free tiers exist; paid is typically a few dollars a month.
- Built into your platform (Apple Passwords, Google Password Manager): free, excellent within one ecosystem, weaker across ecosystems and for sharing outside the family.
- Local-only (KeePassXC and friends): free, open source, no cloud, you handle sync and backups yourself. Best for people who want full control and are willing to do the work.
Hashword does not currently review or recommend specific products, and has no affiliate relationships. Any of the mainstream, audited options above is a sound choice; pick on workflow and price.
Setting the master password
This is the one password you will type from memory, and it protects all the others, so it has two requirements: strong enough to survive an offline attack on a stolen vault, and memorable enough that you will not write it on a sticky note.
The answer is a five-word random passphrase: something like copper-lagoon-frantic-weasel-sonnet, about 65 bits, generated by the passphrase generator, not by you. Type it a dozen times on the first day and it will stick. Never use it anywhere else, and never use anything you have used before. Add two-factor authentication to the manager account itself. Write the recovery kit or emergency code on paper and store it with your passport.
The first week
- Install the browser extension and phone app; enable autofill.
- Import saved passwords from your browser, then turn the browser’s own saving off so there is one source of truth.
- Run the manager’s audit or “watchtower” report. It lists reused, weak and breached passwords.
- Change the reused ones, most important first: email, banking, anything with a card on file. Let the manager generate 20-character random replacements.
- Move your 2FA codes into the manager, or into a dedicated authenticator app if you prefer keeping the factors separate.
- Store security-question answers as random strings too. “Mother’s maiden name:
Wq7!vLp2xR” is perfectly valid.
Everything after that is maintenance the manager mostly does for you. The guide on password reuse explains what you have just protected yourself from.