What to Do in the First Hour After a Data Breach

A checklist, in order, with the tools to do each step. Most of the damage from a breach happens in the days after, to people who did nothing.

First, confirm it is real

Breach notifications are themselves a favourite phishing lure. “Your account was compromised, click here to secure it” is the oldest trick there is. Do not click anything in the message. Open a new tab, type the site’s address yourself, and log in. If the site has been breached, it will say so on its own pages or in your account. You can also search the site’s name on Have I Been Pwned, which catalogues confirmed breaches.

If the notification came from HIBP itself or from your password manager’s breach monitor, it is real; those services do not send links to reset pages.

Minute 0–15: the breached account

  1. Change the password on the breached site to a fresh one from the random password generator, stored in your password manager. Do not modify the old one; a changed digit is the first thing attackers try.
  2. Log out of all sessions if the site offers it (usually under security settings). Attackers who already logged in keep their session otherwise.
  3. Turn on two-factor authentication while you are in the security settings. An authenticator app, not SMS, if the choice exists. Our 2FA guide explains which to pick.
  4. Check recovery settings. Attackers add their own email or phone as a recovery method so they can get back in later. Remove anything you do not recognise.

Minute 15–45: everywhere you reused it

This is the step that matters most and that most people skip. The leaked password will be tried against every major site within hours, automatically, by scripts. If it opens your email, the attacker can reset everything else.

  1. Email first. If the breached password, or anything like it, was also your email password, change the email password now and enable 2FA there.
  2. Run the breach checker. Paste the old password into the breach checker. Only five characters of its hash leave your browser. If it is in the corpus, it is in every attacker’s wordlist for ever.
  3. Find the reuse. A password manager’s audit feature lists every account sharing a password. Without one, go through banking, shopping, social media and work accounts and change any that used the same or a similar password. Our guide on password reuse explains why “similar” counts.

Minute 45–60: what else leaked

Breach notices list the exposed fields. Each one has a consequence:

  • Email address: expect targeted phishing that references the breached site. Be suspicious of anything mentioning it for months.
  • Phone number: expect smishing and, if you use SMS 2FA, SIM-swap risk. Move important accounts to app-based 2FA.
  • Password hash: if the site used bcrypt or Argon2 and your password was strong, you have time. If it used MD5 or SHA-1, or you are not told, assume it is cracked.
  • Card number: call the bank, get a new card. Watch statements for small test charges.
  • Government ID, date of birth, address: consider a credit freeze with the bureaus in your country; it is free and reversible.
  • Security questions: those answers are now public. Change them everywhere to random strings stored in your manager; nobody checks whether your “first pet” was really Xk3#pL9q.

The following weeks

  • Enable breach monitoring: HIBP’s free notifications for your email addresses, and your password manager’s built-in watch.
  • Check bank and card statements once a week for a month.
  • Treat every unexpected “verify your account” message as phishing until proven otherwise; the guide on spotting phishing covers the tells.
  • If the breach was at your employer or a service you administer, follow the incident process: rotate shared secrets and API keys (the key generator helps), revoke sessions, and audit who accessed what.

Make the next one boring

The reason the first hour after a breach is stressful is reuse. If every account has its own random password, a breach anywhere is a one-account problem: change that password, enable 2FA, done. That is the state a password manager and half an hour can put you in. The password manager guide is the place to start.

New tools and guides, about once a month.

No tracking pixels, no upsells. Unsubscribe with one click.

Newsletter